Before I even begin this review, I want to take note of Maxime Béland, the creative director for Blacklist, said to Kirk Hamilton at Kotaku during press event. This was also noted in his review of the game as well.
“Our lead writer on Blacklist is Richard Dansky,” Béland said. “When I called him, I said, ‘Hey Richard, we’re making Splinter Cell six, do you want to write it for us? And his first question was, ‘Do I need to come up with a story that’s gonna require Sam to take out 800 guys?’ And I paused for a second and I said… ‘This is sad, Richard, but I think so. We can talk about it, but I think at the end of the day… we want it to be more and more “ghost,” [to have non-lethal options], but yeah, at the end of the day, it’s just Sam Fisher and bad guys and maps, right?'”
In all honesty, this quote may be the best way to sum up Splinter Cell: Blacklist. With the absence of Michael Ironside as Sam Fisher’s voice, Sam Fisher has become a generic military character. His voice sounds younger and his appearance altered into a more youthful complexion that seems strange when you take Sam’s age into consideration (you also then have to wonder how he’s still in the field if he’s that old, as well).
Now why is this important? How could a voice be so important to a game and how the hell does this connect to the quote? Well we lose the true essence of who Sam Fisher is to us. We lose intense moments of dialogue like this (Conviction spoiler) and end up with this (potential Blacklist spoilers).
Normally, the main character, tied to a chair, and submitted to the hands of the big baddie is normally a rather dramatic and intense scene; however, most of the tension is lost in Sam’s new grunt-like voice. The dialogue can be well written at times but without Ironside’s masculine purr as Sam Fisher the story takes a serious dramatic toll.
Voice acting aside, the story arc is the normal scenario you’d expect from a Tom Clancy game. Terrorists called ‘The Engineers’ have created a plot titled ‘Blacklist’ that destroys key America cities and figures until America agrees to withdraw troops from every country in the world and cease their global operations.
Now if you don’t ask questions like, why the hell would they publicly display a timer and their targets or how the achieved an army, then you should have a mildly enjoyable action-packed ride; however, the various twists and turns will inevitably roll over you as you discover the Engineers true plan (because there’s always some ridiculous underlying plan) and you then give up asking questions and take them out as Sam ‘The Generic’ Fisher.
I know I sound unenthused about the whole Tom Clancy narrative but it’s what I expected from Blacklist and I can’t say I’m entirely disappointed. I mean, if I look at it outside of the franchise it’s not half bad but within it, well then, we have a problem.
To sum up my issue with the story, Sam Fisher needs a send-off. Give him something simple, something family-oriented, or hell, make him the director of some new Splinter Cell (aka Fourth Echelon) and just use Michael Ironside’s voice. I don’t care how you do it but it needs to end for him.
Regardless of all this story mumbo-jumbo, the casual gamer is probably wondering about the action, gameplay, explosions, hot chicks, and multiplayer. Fortunately for you, Blacklist has all of that.
The gameplay within the story and in, just about every other multiplayer mode condenses into three potential playing styles: Ghost, Panther, and Assault. Ghost narrows down to sticking to the shadows and avoiding detection at all costs. Panther is essentially killing and/or taking enemies out from the shadows while Assault is straight up neglecting shadows and shooting everyone in sight. The player earns points in each that accumulate to a lump sum of money that can be used to purchase the orgasmic amounts of gear that Tom Clancy fans love about the Clancyverse.
The mechanics work much like a free-flowing point and click cover system. Sam gets behind cover, looks at another piece of cover, the player clicks a button, and Sam does a quick little shimmy to that piece of cover. The enemies (when undisturbed) follow a systematic path while the player slips in between the gaps. This system works well in a stealth atmosphere but truly falls apart during a firefight. In fact, you’ll really feel how poorly constructed it is when the campaign forces you into predetermined firefights or when you’ve been discovered and must shoot your way out.
Although the diversity of rewards for different playstyles is appreciated, it focuses too much attention on the Panther playstyle. It’s the easiest and most common playstyle but its emphasis can hinder the experience for players who enjoy playing as Ghost or Assault. The evidence appears both in the predetermined campaign firefights and the clunky firefight mechanics (however, keep in mind that there is a Perfectionist difficulty for players who don’t want to play Blacklist in full stealth).
Multiplayer and alternative game modes can be accessed on the Paladin (the airplane/HQ) from each individual character on board. Kirk Williams, from Kotaku, describes the side missions perfectly in his review:
The side missions are as follows: Anna Grímsdóttir, Sam’s long-suffering commander, assigns a ream of stealth challenges that have Sam sneaking into buildings and planting bugs, instantly failing if he gets spotted a single time. Charlie, a “cool young tech whiz” character (Signifiers: He wears a hoodie and calls his friends “his peeps”) offers a series of survival-based challenges that have Sam and an optional-but-basically-necessary co-op partner surviving 20 increasingly difficult waves of enemies while waiting for extraction. Kobin, an arms dealer who becomes Sam’s prisoner after the first mission, assigns a number of “terrorist hunt” level-clearing assignments. And Briggs, a hotheaded new addition from the CIA, offers a short campaign’s worth of co-op only missions that are closer to the single-player story missions, except designed for two people.
These missions are engaging and really bring the co-operative gameplay players loved from Chaos Theory to life but ultimately suffer from the same mechanics as the rest of the game. There is also the fact that split-screen co-operative play forces the second player to play as a guest voiding them of acquiring any co-operative achievements or trophies. Oh, and if you’re looking for eye-candy, Anna Grímsdóttir got a foxy make over, so if you’re into that, there’s that too.
As for the multiplayer, Blacklist borrows the beloved Spies vs. Mercs game mode from Pandora Tomorrow and tweak a bit. The most notable game mode is Spies vs. Mercs Classic. Spies must sneak around and hack terminals while Mercs run around trying to take them out. Mercs are big lumbering enemies holding some powerful assault rifles but limited to a first-person perspective while the spies are carbon copied Sam Fishers with a few less gadgetry.
The other game modes can fun but classic simply can’t be beat. There’s nothing better than the cat-and-mouse gameplay of spies hacking a terminal and the mercs come running to investigate and defend. The spies, as of launch, are a bit overpowered with their close proximity insta-kills but I’m sure that Ubisoft will fix a few things in time. So what may be unbalanced now might be fixed in later updates.
Cumulatively, Splinter Cell: Blacklist is a decent addition to the franchise and good final addition to the end of the console generation. It brings together what gamers loved and puts it all in one good game. It offers new players a chance to join in the fun and really brings the Splinter Cell we’ve come to enjoy back to life. The only thing I had hoped for was something different from the usual mold of Tom Clancy games. Maybe in time though, that might just change.
It’s a strong game with mechanics that fit most playstyles but it isn’t anything revolutionary or groundbreaking. I can’t say that I’d suggest players to buy it new but it’s certainly worth looking into. It’s fun and an excellent collaboration of the things gamers loved about Splinter Cell (with the exclusion of Michael Ironside’s voice).